Memoir Plus: When Personal Stories Contain Multitudes Was a Smash Success at WMG

WMG group

What if the starting point for a memoir is a question you can’t answer from your own experience alone?

That’s one of the ideas we explored on October 21 at Memoir Plus: When Personal Stories Contain Multitudes, the panel I curated and moderated for Women’s Media Group in the Toni Morrison Room at Penguin Random House.

For Laura Carney, the list of adventures her father left behind gave My Father’s List a grounded form that provided structure and a way to write about grief through what she did next. Bethany Saltman talked about how her curiosity about attachment science helped shape Strange Situation and how motherhood gave her a personal way into that inquiry. And in Docile, Hyeseung Song examines how family expectations and the model-minority myth shaped her ideas about success.

I moderated, but also joined the conversation as a writer. In my own nonfiction project, I’m blending memoir, reporting, and cultural critique to explore how the relationship advice I helped sell as a women’s magazine editor shaped my own ideas about love.

As I put the panel together, I wanted to ask Bethany and Regina, who are both literary agents, a question I’ve wrestled with in my own work. When you’re blending memoir with reporting or cultural criticism, what do you lead with when you pitch the book? The personal story? The question you’re investigating?

Regina approached the book from the publishing side. She encouraged writers to read comparable books and ask what their own approach would add. She also talked about the value of a community of readers who already care about the subject. Bethany added a point that resonated for me. Sometimes the question comes first.

If you’re working on a memoir, try this with a scene you keep coming back to. What did you believe in that moment? What did you have to learn, investigate, or ask someone else before you could see it differently? That’s one place to look for your “plus.”

Thank you to Laura, Hyeseung, Bethany, and Regina for joining me, to Women’s Media Group and Kathy Sandler for hosting us at Penguin Random House, and to the friends, students, and colleagues who came, asked questions, and stayed to talk afterward.

Here are some highlights from the evening.

2 Responses to “Memoir Plus: When Personal Stories Contain Multitudes Was a Smash Success at WMG”

  1. JULIA A. ERGOVICH

    Estelle has helped me considerably with memoir in my personal essays. Posing a question in memoir and then answering it is a compelling and thought provoking way to write from life.

    Reply
    • Estelle

      Thank you Julia. I’m so happy that you’ve found my work and advice so helpful in your memoir journey.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *